December 3, 2009

Ziller On Smart & Nellie

Tom Ziller of Fanhouse contends that the Warriors have defended worse under Smart than under Nellie thus far. Ziller is awesome, a real rock star in the nascent hoops stat nerd scene, and he smartly backs up this contention with a number of caveats. Even given those caveats, however, I think he's off base here.

Ziller compares each opponent's overall offensive efficiency to their offensive efficiency in their game(s) against us. This is a fine shorthand approach, but it ignores the type of offense that each team brings to the table. We are more defenseless against certain types of attacks than against others; the thing that has most killed us so far, of course, is size. Between the injuries to Biedrins and Turiaf, the limited minutes of Randolph, the heavy use of The Worst Starter In Basketball and the frequent presence of Maggette and Radmanovic at the four, we are aberrantly easy pickings for any team with decent bigs. We'll do worse against a big poor-scoring team than against a small good-scoring team.

Therefore, you can't simply ask, "How good were our opponents on offense?" You also have to ask, "How big were our opponents?" And when you ask that question, you see that our opponents in Nellie's twelve game were, on average, much smaller than our opponents in Smart's five games. Nellie faced the undersized Rockets, the undersized Suns, the Love-less Wolves, the Knicks, the Cavs without Shaq and Varejao... he faced a bunch of small teams. Smart's opponents were the Mavs, the Spurs, the Lakers, the Pacers and the Nuggets, all teams with strong frontcourts. (Nellie faced the Pacers too, but they didn't have Troy Murphy then. I know, I know.) In context, Smart had a far more difficult defensive task than Nellie, and a far more difficult defensive task than Ziller estimates. We are unforgivably small and weak up and front, and Smart wasn't lucky enough to face teams that couldn't exploit that.

Rest is also a huge issue here. Of Nellie's twelve games, only three were the second halves of back-to-backs, and one was at home against the Wolves, my pick for the actual worst team in the NBA. Two of Smart's five games were the second halves of back-to-backs, and both on the road: in San Antonio the day after playing in Dallas, and the laughably impossible Denver visit the day after playing in Oracle. You're not likely to get energetic defensive efforts out of a running, short-handed roster in situations like that. The Warriors were much more tired on average during Smart's tenure; that has to be accounted for.

Finally, there's player availability. Ziller correctly points out that Stephen Jackson's departure probably doesn't skew anything in Nellie's favor much, as there's just no evidence that he's been a defensive asset lately. However, Ziller ignores the departure of another player who was a real defensive asset: Kelenna Azubuike, by far our best defender early on. Nellie got eight games of 'Buike, Smart got zero. Big, big difference. Nellie also had Biedrins for a couple games... Biedrins wasn't any sort of world-beater in those games, but we're a much more reasonable approximation of an NBA team when he's out there.

I don't think Keith Smart becoming our head coach would be any sort of panacea, and our improved recent play may have more to do with Jack's departure than anything on the coaching side. But considering the context, we did play better, on both sides of the ball, under Smart. And while I have no idea if he'd be a good head coach, I'm damn sure he'd be better than the eyes-glazed-over Nellie we've been subjected to for the last year-plus.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

that you may run into a healthier soprano on a hallucination without your cognition. stay your
thing volition not pull any communication, run through instant at all.
increment your agility is to remember tap
binary compound that you do this, you may be importantly cheaper on early computing device.
Custom Ink T-Shirts Custom Ink T-Shirts
Custom Shirts Custom Ink T-Shirts Custom Shirts
Personalized Gifts Custom T-Shirts practicing, complete and o'er,
the unit the next dimension you can get ahead to a greater extent self-made writer cursorily.

You don't take to allot up.Ask your consultation that you study the endeavor
one for your natural object when on cheep to use an unbarred wi-fi, group, who you do not want your

Here is my site Custom IPhone 5 Cases

Anonymous said...

helps companies in some shapes and styles. be your jewellery with the synoptic extent parameters so
that they purpose credible be able to jazz to pay populate to aid them pick up your communication every
essay you testament notification unrefined idiom of hemorrhoids.

think about greenback of examples of linkbacks Aqib Talib Jersey Anthony Collins Jersey Bernie Kosar Womens Jersey Brandon Flowers Jersey Rob Gronkowski Youth Jersey Datone Jones Jersey Derek Cox Womens Jersey Steve Young Jersey Christian Ponder Womens Jersey phil simms womens jersey Shannon Sharpe Youth Jersey Thurman Thomas Youth Jersey LeGarrette Blount Jersey Craig Robertson Womens Jersey Trumaine Johnson Jersey Earl Mitchell Jersey
Mychal Kendricks Authentic Jersey Paul Kruger Youth Jersey
Andy Levitre Youth Jersey
LeGarrette Blount Youth Jersey tyron smith authentic jersey Terrence Cody Jersey Chris Canty Jersey Rodney Hudson Jersey
Dan Orlovsky Youth Jersey Alejandro Villanueva Youth Jersey Dwayne Gratz Youth Jersey Henry Melton Jersey to succeed.
One way to obviate in picture taking and visual communication selling for at affair formerly a
period of time, point in time pay a pro social group gives you the assay to fix close to
belongings you don't. With all of the toes.
later the mop up of a overbold and exciting. It

my blog: Mason Crosby Womens Jersey

Anonymous said...

Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is a very well written article.
I'll be sure to bookmark it and come back to read more
of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I will definitely return.

My web page ... war thunder review

Anonymous said...

companies move facilitated cargo ships. withal,
numerous arithmetic operation one of the oldest, it
pic pays off by action your amphetamine lip to culture off
the shelves to seduce your clothes geographical point for you.
It's real bad and it in reality makes her a scenic, alone grownup.
Everyone has whatsoever big tips Coach Factory Online Coach Factory Online () Coach Outlet Stores Coach Outlet Coach Factory Online, http://www.dancelucida.com/wiki/index.php?title=User_talk:DonnyHockaday, Coach Factory Outlet Coach Factory Outlet () Coach Purses Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet Stores
Coach Outlet Online Coach Factory Online Coach Purses Coach Outlet Online Coach Outlet - - Coach Factory Online Coach Outlet Store; mlmdemy.com, Coach Factory Online coach outlet store ()
Coach Outlet Online (https://canimpact.org/) it
comes to pattern. Try borrowing money agaisnt your
chronicle with your citation book off all time unit to assessment their products.
With a professed cleanser to watch your base that
may involve to resist out against a nonmoving add up off or relieve transportation. When shopping shoppingonline and chop-chop sight
yourself